Growing Also Means Changing Your Mind
Having clear ideas is often considered a sign of confidence. Knowing what you think, being able to defend it, and not being easily influenced by others are qualities we tend to associate with maturity and the development of an independent personality. Changing your mind, on the other hand, can be interpreted as a form of inconsistency or indecision: if yesterday I thought one thing and today I think something different, which version of me is the right one?
And yet, growing inevitably means discovering something we did not know before. It means having experiences, meeting people, engaging with different points of view, making mistakes, and acquiring new knowledge. And if all of this never changed, at least in part, the way we look at reality, could we really speak of growth?
Changing your mind does not necessarily mean giving up your convictions. Sometimes it means taking them seriously enough to be willing to question them.
This is a particularly important ability at a time when we are constantly called upon to take a position. Opinions are expressed quickly, dialogue risks turning into confrontation, and recognizing something valuable in another person’s point of view can almost seem like a defeat. Education can therefore open up a different kind of space: one in which it is important not only to learn to say “this is what I think,” but also to have the freedom to ask “why do I think this?” and, sometimes, “does what I have encountered still allow me to think in the same way?”
When Experience Challenges What We Think
Not all our convictions arise from conscious reflection. Some come from the environment in which we grew up, others from the people around us, from the experiences we have had, or simply from what we have always taken for granted. This does not necessarily make them wrong, but it does mean that growing also requires the possibility of putting them to the test of reality.
This can happen through a book that presents a perspective we had never considered, a lesson that reveals the complexity of an apparently simple issue, a journey, a service project, a mistake, or an encounter with someone whose story challenges one of our prejudices. In these moments, the educational experience does more than add new information: it changes the way we look at what we already knew.
This dynamic is particularly significant in Ignatian pedagogy. Experience, in fact, is not considered sufficient on its own. What we experience needs to be revisited and reflected upon: what happened? What did it awaken in me? What had I not seen before? What do I understand differently now? It is through reflection that experience can become learning and lead to new choices.
The movement between experience, reflection, and action, central to the Ignatian Pedagogical Paradigm, describes an educational approach that does not see the person as something static. What we come to understand through experience can transform our judgement and, consequently, the way we act. Changing perspective, therefore, does not necessarily represent a break in the journey: it can be one of its most authentic outcomes.
Critical Thinking Also Requires Freedom
We often speak about the need to develop critical thinking. But thinking critically does not simply mean knowing how to question what others say. It also means being able to apply the same attention to our own convictions.
This is probably the most difficult part. Recognizing that we do not have all the information, realizing that a position was too simplistic, or admitting that someone else’s point of view has helped us understand something better requires a particular kind of freedom. It means not completely identifying ourselves with every opinion we express.
This distinction is especially important in education. If changing one’s mind is perceived as a defeat, it will be natural to defend a position even when new evidence emerges. If, instead, school succeeds in showing that revising a judgement in the light of new evidence is part of the process of learning, then dialogue can cease to be a competition in which someone necessarily has to win.
A classroom discussion, for example, does not serve only to teach students how to argue their own position. It can teach them to listen to an objection, distinguish a fact from an interpretation, recognize a weakness in their own reasoning, and incorporate something they have learned from another person. In the same way, studying often means discovering that reality is more complex than the categories through which we initially viewed it.
From this perspective, having an open mind does not mean believing that all ideas are equally valid or giving up firmly held convictions. It means being willing to continually examine how well what we think stands up to reality.
A School Where We Can Say “I Changed My Mind”
For this to happen, however, the educational environment must also make room for uncertainty. A student must be able to formulate a hypothesis, discover that it does not work, revise it, and begin again without experiencing every correction as a failure. They must be able to ask a question without already having the answer and engage with different ideas without feeling that listening to them necessarily means agreeing with them.
From this point of view, the educator is not simply the person who leads students towards the correct answer. Educators can also show, through the way they teach, that knowledge is a process: it deepens, is corrected, and returns to what once seemed settled. Even saying “I don’t know,” “we need to explore this further,” or “this changes the way we can look at the issue” can have significant educational value.
This perspective is consistent with Fondazione Gesuiti Educazione’s focus on the integral formation of the person and on discernment. The aim is not to form young people without convictions, but people capable of developing them consciously, testing them against experience, and taking responsibility for their choices. People who know how to take a position, while also preserving the inner freedom necessary to continue learning.
Perhaps one of the most interesting questions a school can leave its students with is not only “what have you learned?”, but also: “is there something you see differently today from the way you saw it before?”
Because growing does not simply mean accumulating answers. It means allowing what we encounter to question us, recognizing when a conviction needs to be explored more deeply, and having the courage to change our perspective when we come to understand something new.
Share
